Seyfried's Meta Twist in Fielder's Holmes Documentary — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- "You Can See Everything" chronicles the 34 days before Holmes began her 11-year prison sentence, then introduces a meta twist halfway through by enlisting Amanda Seyfried — who won an Emmy playing Holmes in Hulu's "The Dropout" — to reenact scenes from Fielder's investigation.
- Amanda Seyfried and Christopher Abbott (as Billy Evans) recreate a pre-production negotiation revealing that A24 agreed to pay Evans for participation; Holmes tells Fielder in prison she had no knowledge of the payment, and Evans later dropped his request without explanation.
- Holmes cries when Fielder first shows her Seyfried's "Dropout" performance, and later rants in prison that Seyfried's portrayal contributed to how she's perceived, prompting Seyfried to defend her work as "fiction-land" backed by "ridiculous amounts of research," including 10 hours of deposition tapes.
- Seyfried pushes back at Fielder's questioning, telling him "it's not lies. It's fucking TV" and challenging whether Fielder's reenacted scenes depict a kinder Holmes than the real woman, leaving viewers to question if he's protecting her or playing a heightened version of himself.
- The film ends on a contested New York Times quote attributed to Holmes — "They're not playing me. They're playing a character I created" — though Holmes claims the Times misquoted her as saying "I created" rather than "they created," a single-word discrepancy the documentary leaves viewers to adjudicate.
Why it matters: By having a fictional actress reenact exchanges the filmmakers couldn't film, "You Can See Everything" blurs the boundary between documentary and performance art — and the documentary never resolves whether Fielder is exposing or shielding Holmes. The film's thesis collapses into one disputed NYT quote where swapping "I" for "they" determines whether Holmes admits fraud or blames the show, leaving viewers as the final arbiters of her guilt.
Ask SkimNews
