Rival clubs want retrospective and future punishments for Man City — SkimNews
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Premier League clubs want Manchester City to receive retrospective punishments and future sanctions for breaching financial rules between 2009-10 and 2017-18, arguing that a single points deduction would be insufficient given the scale of wrongdoing
- Manchester City were found guilty by an independent commission of all charges related to Premier League financial regulation breaches across nine seasons, prompting appeals from the club and scrutiny from the Solicitors Regulation Authority
- Rival club executives believe any punishment should include reparations for past advantages and long-term limitations on City’s competitiveness, with some advocating for multi-season points deductions and extended transfer bans
- One senior club source said Manchester City should be stripped of their eight major trophies won during the违规 period, warning that the league’s credibility is at risk if they retain them, though BBC Sport previously reported limited appetite for redistribution
- Club sources have suggested a tariff-based system to calculate financial reparations, where rival teams could be compensated based on altered league positions due to hypothetical historical points deductions
- Premier League figures argue that a one-season sanction would only be a 'bump in the road' for City, emphasizing that penalties must span multiple seasons to meaningfully disrupt their dominance
Why it matters: If implemented, multi-season sanctions and trophy removal would materially alter Manchester City’s legacy and redistribute competitive balance in the Premier League, while financial reparations could shift millions between clubs based on recalculated standings — stakes that go far beyond a single season’s outcome.
Ask SkimNews
