AI Songs Hit Charts as Labels Seek Disqualification Rules
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Fenix Flexin's "Rubberz" climbed to #58 on the Billboard Hot 100 with over 35M Spotify streams; he admitted using Treblo's AI tool after DJ-producer Medasin posted a side-by-side video showing he could reproduce the track with similar prompts.
- Universal Music Group, Sony Music, and Warner Music Group proposed on July 29 disqualifying AI-generated tracks from global charts unless they are properly authorized, lawful, and substantially human-made.
- Billboard confirmed at least six AI-generated or AI-assisted artists debuted on its various charts in 2025, including Breaking Rust's "Walk My Walk" at #1 on country digital song sales and Xania Monet, who signed a reported multimillion-dollar record deal.
- Deezer and Ipsos found 97% of survey participants couldn't distinguish AI from human-made music, while Luminate found 44% of US respondents felt less inclined to listen to songs involving generative AI.
- Suno and Udio remain in active copyright litigation with major labels—Universal settled with Udio and Warner settled with both in 2024—even as labels announced AI-tool partnerships with Nvidia, Spotify, Stability AI, and Suno.
- Tyga's AI-created album $tarface received Pitchfork's first 0.0 review in nearly two decades, as artists including SZA, Billie Eilish, Nick Cave, and Paul McCartney publicly condemned AI music generators.
- Spotify rolled out "AI Persona" tags that exclude those artists from personalized recommendations, while Bandcamp banned AI music and Tidal stripped royalties from fully AI-generated tracks.
Why it matters: The labels' proposed chart rules don't ban AI—they permit it if songs are 'substantially human-made,' a carve-out that protects their own partnerships with Nvidia, Suno, and Stability AI while shutting out independent AI-driven acts like Xania Monet. With 44% of listeners already turned off by AI music and 97% unable to identify it on Deezer, the rules double as both a consumer-protection gesture and a competitive moat.
Ask SkimNews
