'Motor City': A Dialogue-Free Thriller Driven by Needle Drops
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- "Motor City" is a dialogue-free crime thriller set in 1977 Detroit that opens July 24; it was directed by Potsy Ponciroli and written by Chad St. John, with characters speaking only an occasional throwaway word.
- Alan Ritchson stars as John Miller, an ex-con and Vietnam veteran framed by a drug kingpin who plants kilos of narcotics in his car, earning him a 25-year prison sentence.
- Shailene Woodley plays Sophia, Miller's fiancée whom the kingpin takes back, while Ben Foster plays Reynolds, the wealthy and powerful drug lord who engineers the setup.
- Ponciroli uses needle drops — including Fleetwood Mac's "The Chain," David Bowie's "Cat People," Donna Summer's "I Feel Love," and Moody Blues' "Nights in White Satin" — as operatic scene-setters that carry the film's emotion in place of dialogue.
- The review credits Ponciroli with audacious formal choices but flags the final act as a letdown: the needle drops disappear and are replaced by "a blandly orthodox suspense score," possibly because song rights were lost.
- Ponciroli's previous film, the 2021 Western "Old Henry" starring Tim Blake Nelson, was praised by the same reviewer as "sneaky" and "stylish," framing "Motor City" as a follow-up that broadens his stylistic range.
Why it matters: Ponciroli's structural gamble — staging an entire crime film without dialogue and leaning on needle drops for emotional weight — establishes him, per the reviewer, as a filmmaker worth a major studio bet, even as the same review concedes the final act undermines the conceit by reverting to conventional scoring.
Ask SkimNews
