Peacock's 'Five-Star Weekend' Ditches the Murder Trope
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- 'The Five-Star Weekend' is a Peacock limited series adapted from Elin Hilderbrand's novel by Bekah Brunstetter ('This Is Us'), with all eight episodes now streaming on the platform.
- Jennifer Garner (also an executive producer) stars as food influencer Hollis Shaw, who invites one friend from each life phase to her childhood Nantucket home for 72 hours of bonding, six months after her husband died in a car accident.
- The series deliberately rejects the murder-mystery template popularized by 'Big Little Lies' and 'The White Lotus,' instead centering medium-term grief, midlife reinvention, and frank discussions of perimenopause among its group of middle-aged women.
- Hilderbrand's previous Peacock adaptation, 'The Perfect Couple,' used murder as a core element at a New England destination wedding — 'The Five-Star Weekend' marks a tonal departure from how the author's work has been treated onscreen.
- The ensemble includes Chloë Sevigny as a resentful childhood friend, Regina Hall as a sports agent and college bestie, D'Arcy Carden as an insecure 'mom friend,' Gemma Chan as an online follower-turned-pilot, Timothy Olyphant as Garner's high school ex, and Judy Greer in a recurring mean-girl role.
- The show doesn't punish Hollis for her success — her Martha Stewart-style domesticity is framed as a legitimate trauma response to losing her nuclear family rather than a target for satire, a stance the reviewer flags as rare in current prestige TV.
Why it matters: The review positions 'The Five-Star Weekend' as deliberate counterprogramming to the murder-saturated prestige model that has dominated affluent-people-in-beautiful-locations dramas since 'Big Little Lies' — offering eight episodes of midlife emotional realism without a corpse driving the plot. For Peacock, the show extends its Hilderbrand pipeline in a different tonal direction than 'The Perfect Couple,' and for viewers exhausted by whodunits, it argues for a kind of slower, grief-centered storytelling that's become vanishingly rare on streaming.
