Laurie Kilmartin's London Debut: Filthy, Fierce, Half-Formed
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Laurie Kilmartin, a Peabody award-winning US comedian and staff writer for Jimmy Kimmel and Conan O'Brien, made her London debut with what the review calls a "scattergun" hour mixing penis jokes, free-bleeding stories and revenge material.
- The comedian, who wrote on the last two Oscars ceremonies, delivers her darkest anecdotes — including a story of an abusive swim coach — with "furred-brow intensity" before flashing an "are-you-gonna-take-it smile."
- Kilmartin cycles through school bullies, the need for better assassins, and the limited dating pool of men over 50, though some material lands flat: a lockdown bit lingers past its moment and a Charlie Kirk joke "missed the moment."
- Visible mid-show math conversions and reference checks signal Kilmartin is not yet calibrated to UK audiences, and she repeatedly flags herself as an American single mum against a crowd that is neither.
- The hour's structure is "loose and fragmented," with weaker audience-participation segments — including a callback to a language-failure story set in Japan that came from an audience member, not the comedian.
- Though Kilmartin repeatedly dismisses the crowd as "light clappers," the reviewer notes her standoffish tone only makes the audience laugh harder, matching "the clean brutality of her best anecdotes."
Why it matters: For fans of US comedy crossing the Atlantic, the review positions Kilmartin's London debut as a rough-edged showcase — her punchiest material still lands, but the show plays as a work-in-progress, with dated references and crowd-work rough spots that suggest she has yet to tailor her voice for British rooms.
