Siri AI Wins Beta Praise but Users Drift Back to Old Habits — SkimNews
Get the Tech newsletter
Daily tech — startups, AI labs, chips, the launches that shape the next decade. Free.
- The writer tested Apple's Siri AI in the iOS 27 developer beta by using it as a San Francisco tour guide, initially calling the chatbot-style interface "very Apple-y" and reliable enough to feel like an "everything tool."
- Siri AI's on-device indexing of personal phone contents made it the writer's fastest method of retrieving old text messages and photos, with world knowledge and dictation also described as vastly better than before.
- The writer's usage tapered over the summer despite the upgrades, as old habits like Instagram doomscrolling and manual Yelp searches returned; the writer was already "low-key locked in" with Anthropic's Claude as a separate chatbot.
- Forrester's Dipanjan Chatterjee said the "vast installed base of iPhone users" will not defect over Siri's quality, since everyday consumers default to Apple's software and trust Apple with their data in ways they don't with other AI companies.
- IDC's Ramon Llamas argued Apple's long-cultivated privacy reputation could win over users who previously had "qualms about the safety of other AI tools" but are open to trying Siri inside Apple's ecosystem.
- Techsponential's Avi Greengart, a former Siri skeptic, said he is now using the beta Siri more than ever, calling it faster than any other method for finding buried phone information.
- An anti-AI segment of iPhone owners may reject Siri AI outright regardless of feature gains, driven by moral objections or broader distrust of generative AI tools.
- iOS 27 beta testers' reactions split between power users drifting back to defaults and everyday consumers staying inside Apple's walled garden, leaving Apple's distribution advantage intact.
Why it matters: Apple's privacy reputation and massive installed base insulate Siri AI from competition even when power users drift away. Forrester's Chatterjee notes everyday iPhone users default to Apple's software regardless of Siri's quality relative to rivals like Anthropic's Claude, giving Apple a captive distribution channel competitors can't replicate. Whether Apple converts AI-skeptical consumers (per IDC's Llamas) or loses holdouts to anti-AI sentiment will determine whether on-device AI becomes a real moat or a niche feature.
Ask SkimNews
