John Early Plays Bulimic Chef in Directorial Debut
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- John Early wrote, directed, and stars in "Maddie's Secret," his feature directorial debut, playing Maddie, a rising food influencer at the fictional "GourMaybe Test Kitchen" whose bulimia resurges as her online star rises
- Early cited Bon Appétit test kitchen videos as a 2020 pandemic comfort, then watched the online food space pivot to what he calls "pornographic" low-angle, ASMR-style cooking content — the throughline that inspired the film
- The film takes satirical and aesthetic cues from Paul Verhoeven's "Showgirls" (1995) and "Starship Troopers" (1997), with Early saying he wanted audiences in a state of "tonal confusion" after laughing hard enough to be open to emotion
- Early initially tried mounting the story with a gay male lead but found it "caustic"; shifting to playing Maddie as a woman — in a blond wig, breast prosthetics, and hip pads — unlocked what he calls a "maternal," gentler artistic register
- The cast is stacked with Early's comedy-world friends, including Kate Berlant as an overbearing sapphic best friend, plus Vanessa Bayer, Conner O'Malley, Kristen Johnston, and Eric Rahill, with filming at Early's actual house and his ex-boyfriend Gordon Landenberger as production designer
- The bulimia research drew on the documentary "Thin" (2006), the 1978 book "The Best Little Girl in the World," conversations with a friend who went to inpatient treatment, and Amy Sedaris's recommendation of Cherry Boone O'Neill's "Starving for Attention"
- The film also satirizes FX's "The Bear" via a rival show called "The Boar," layering food-world critique, queer relationship tension, and Single White Female energy onto its central eating-disorder drama
Why it matters: Early's pivot from caustic millennial-comic persona to playing a bulimic woman — in a Verhoeven-inflected, friend-staffed indie — signals a real artistic reinvention rather than a one-joke parody, and the film's pointed swipes at the sexualization of food-influencer content give the eating-disorder drama a timely, media-critique edge.
