PTA's Cameron Winter Carnegie Hall Doc: Hypnotic, Tender — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Paul Thomas Anderson directed and self-shot "Cameron Winter at Carnegie Hall," a 72-minute film captured with his own Panavision camera during Winter's December solo performance to a sold-out crowd of more than 2,700.
- Cameron Winter, frontman of the art-rock band Geese, performed sparse piano arrangements from his solo album "Heavy Metal" — songs like the single "$0" and "Love Takes Miles" are stripped to their emotional core.
- Janus Films is distributing the film roadshow-style, with a theatrical release starting November 20 following its world premiere at the New York Film Festival's Alice Tully Hall; the Criterion Collection is the expected next stop.
- Benny Safdie served as co-producer, contributing to what the reviewer calls the film's "scratchy New York quality and setting."
- "Cameron Winter at Carnegie Hall" is compared to "Stop Making Sense" but framed as a concert movie "for introverts," with Winter's vocal style praised as echoing Harry Nilsson and Van Morrison.
- Winter was 23 at the time of the performance — one year older than Bob Dylan was when he headlined Carnegie Hall — placing him, per the review, "at the precipice of major fame."
Why it matters: The film extends PTA's long pattern of intertwining cinema with music — Fiona Apple videos, Magnolia's Aimee Mann shrine, HAIM, Radiohead scores — now applied to a 23-year-old the review compares to a young Bob Dylan. Janus Films' roadshow theatrical rollout starting November 20 positions Winter as a serious solo voice beyond his band's "wily antic rock chaos," with the Criterion Collection the reported next stop.
Ask SkimNews
.jpg)