'On Behalf of My Son' Review: Premise Outpaces Execution — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- "On Behalf of My Son", directed by Gabriel Martins, is a Brazilian drama set in Belo Horizonte that follows Vicentina (Rejane Faria), the mother of a bus driver, as she tracks down the families of crash victims to apologize on her son's behalf.
- Rejane Faria shoulders nearly the entire 2.5-hour runtime as Vicentina, but the reviewer criticizes her performance as a "near-identical approach to emoting" with "loud thoughts writ large across her face," producing stilted emotions in back-to-back apology scenes.
- Renato Novaes plays both the driver Wesley and his twin brother, whose brief visit to Vicentina's home "practically conjures Wesley's ghost," according to the review.
- Supporting turns stand out where the lead falters: Fábio Leal plays a grieving, battered fiancé harboring complicated feelings, while Giovanni Venturini delivers "heartbreaking" work as Fred, a death-metal frontman with dwarfism and a mysterious friend of Wesley's.
- TV news segments speculating on Wesley's intent and state of mind introduce doubt about whether the crash was deliberate, a thread the reviewer says gestures at "thorny complexities which are never allowed to arise."
- Reviewer praises Martins's "deft eye for place and environment," saying the film's tour of poor Black Brazilian lives hints at "a multifaceted cultural portrait not usually contained within the Brazilian cinema that takes hold in North America" — not since City of God.
- Despite strong individual moments, the review concludes the film "proves rote and repetitive in execution," with each apology visit lacking "meaningful differences until late into the runtime."
Why it matters: Reviewer argues Gabriel Martins's nearly 2.5-hour Brazilian drama burdens lead Rejane Faria with a repetitive performance that undermines the film's rare glimpse into poor Black Brazilian lives. The film gestures at a cultural portrait not seen in North American distribution since City of God, but the rote apology-tour structure prevents those complexities from materializing.
Ask SkimNews
