England player ratings: Spence shines but Bellingham, Rice and Kane fail to deliver
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- England lost 2-1 to Argentina in a World Cup semi-final in Atlanta, with Enzo Fernandez equalizing and Lautaro Martinez heading in a stoppage-time winner after Argentina scored twice in the space of seven minutes late.
- Djed Spence was England's highest-rated player at 8/10 in what the source calls a "surprise inclusion" from Thomas Tuchel, with his tackle on Giuliano Simeone early in the second half flagged as "one of the moments of the match."
- Harry Kane and Declan Rice both received 5/10 — Kane had "no impact whatsoever" and "ploughed a lone furrow," while Rice was "still not at his marauding best" despite returning from illness.
- Jude Bellingham was rated 6/10, "targeted by Argentina" and failing to replicate the impact that defined his earlier tournament performances.
- Elliot Anderson earned 7/10 for shadowing Lionel Messi across the midfield, "heavily involved in what was a heated midfield battle" despite a first-half booking.
- Thomas Tuchel's defensive tactics "backfired," per the source, as England's back line "buckled under Argentina's pressure" after taking the lead through Anthony Gordon's finish from a Morgan Rogers cross.
- Argentina advances to the World Cup final against Spain.
Why it matters: England's tournament ended with their marquee attackers — Kane, Bellingham and Rice — all rated 5 or 6 out of 10, and the source explicitly attributes the collapse to Tuchel's defensive call, saying his tactics "backfired" as Argentina scored twice in the final stages. For Tuchel, it confirms the pre-match concerns about systemic flaws masked by individual brilliance, now exposed on the sport's biggest stage.
