Physics Fixes All the Facts vs The Blind Spot
Get the Health newsletter
Daily health & science — research, biotech, public health, the studies worth knowing. Free.
- Liam Graham argues that reality is ultimately made of quantum fields and that consciousness is an illusion, a view he presents in his book Physics Fixes All the Facts.
- Adam Frank contends that conscious experience is the fundamentally real ingredient of reality, a stance he outlines in The Blind Spot, co‑written with Marcelo Gleiser and Evan Thompson.
- David Papineau is quoted saying that while everything is physical, biology and psychology should not be expected to be explained solely by physics, underscoring the limits of reductionism.
- Emergence is described as the process by which whole properties differ from their parts, with the author noting that consciousness is often treated as a strongly emergent phenomenon.
- Graham dismisses emergence as a misleading concept, calling emergent properties like wetness an illusion and equating belief in strong emergence with believing in pixies.
- Frank argues that because all knowledge comes through experience, scientific theories must keep experience at the center, warning that ignoring it risks losing track of their explanatory limits.
Why it matters: By exposing how the belief that physics alone can explain consciousness versus the view that experience is fundamental drives research agendas, the essay shows that adopting a strictly physicalist stance may marginalize interdisciplinary study, while embracing consciousness as primary could redirect funding and theory‑development toward phenomenology, reshaping the future of scientific inquiry.
Ask SkimNews
