The toughest players to rank at shortstop for 2027: Gunnar Henderson's decline creates a Fantasy dilemma — SkimNews
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Gunnar Henderson has seen his OPS drop from .956 in the first half of 2024 to .708 in 2026, with average exit velocity down nearly 3 mph from 2025 — prompting speculation he may be playing through injury while the author concludes he "doesn't deserve to be treated as one of the elites at the position anymore."
- CJ Abrams is on pace for his first 30-30 season but has slumped to .190/.258/.303 since August 1 with a 33.5% strikeout rate; an inevitable move to second base complicates his long-term fantasy value despite career-best underlying numbers.
- Francisco Lindor has just three steals and a .229 average after a calf injury cost him nearly two months, though his career-low .243 BABIP (.289 lifetime average) suggests possible positive regression as he enters his age-33 season with five years left on his contract.
- Trea Turner ranks as the No. 85 player in Fantasy with 20-20 potential, but his BABIP has plunged from a .333 career mark to .280, his strikeout rate has climbed to 21.3%, and his defense has deteriorated — signs the author says show his "athleticism has taken a hit."
- Corey Seager has rebounded to .297/.368/.510 since the All-Star break after an injury-riddled start, and the author is "kind of excited" to draft him at age 33 given a likely discounted price tag of around pick 150 or later.
- Shortstop entered 2027 with six players in the top 50 of ADP but only five remain in the top 50 heading into the final weekend — a "transitional phase" attributed to aging veterans and unproven replacements like Kevin McGonigle and prospect Konnor Griffin.
Why it matters: Shortstop has anchored Fantasy rosters for years, but with top-50 ADP depth thinning from six players to five and established names like Turner, Seager, and Henderson showing steep decline, drafters face real downside risk paying premium prices for past performance — and the article makes clear no clear-cut replacement tier has emerged yet.
Ask SkimNews
