'Stuart Fails' Review: Big Bang Spinoff Goes Sci-Fi
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- "Stuart Fails to Save the Universe" is the third Big Bang Theory spinoff and the first to air on a streamer (HBO Max) rather than broadcast, distinguishing it from CBS predecessors Young Sheldon (ended 2024) and Georgie & Mandy's First Marriage (currently in season 3).
- Kevin Sussman reprises his comic book store owner Stuart, who travels through alternate dimensions to undo an apocalypse accidentally triggered by members of the original Big Bang crew through a quantum mishap.
- Chuck Lorre and Bill Prady enlisted sci-fi screenwriter Zak Penn (X-Men: The Last Stand) as a collaborator, marking the franchise's first deliberate turn into science fiction rather than physics-themed comedy.
- The core ensemble — Brian Posehn as Bert, John Ross Bowie as warlord Kripke, and Lauren Lapkus as Denise — is transported into a new alternate reality each episode, from steampunk hellscapes and zombie worlds to a society where humans evolved from cows.
- Episodes run as short as 15 minutes with a Danny Elfman theme song and anti-skip credits, allowing original Big Bang stars to make brief cameos as entirely different characters across timelines.
- The review notes the genre pivot sacrifices the 'comforting sameness' of a Big Bang hangout for 'the thrilling potential of a constantly wiped slate.'
Why it matters: The Big Bang Theory franchise has now spawned three spinoffs across broadcast and streaming, but Stuart Fails is the first to abandon the original sitcom template for sci-fi adventure — a structural shift the review frames as a deliberate creative inversion of the property's sitcom comfort. With episodes as short as 15 minutes and a rotating alternate-reality premise, this is the most aggressive format departure the franchise has attempted under Lorre's stewardship.
