London Musical on Nigella Lawson Criticized for
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Emily Rose Simons wrote the two‑hander musical about Nigella Lawson, titled "How to Make a Mess."
- Grace Taylor directed the production at Upstairs at the Gatehouse in London, which runs until 28 June.
- Tanya Truman portrays Nigella Lawson, delivering a performance that avoids full caricature while still employing signature Nigella‑isms.
- Natasha Karp plays Anna, whose grief‑driven storyline is sparked when she opens her father’s cookbook How to Eat and Nigella emerges from a kitchen cupboard.
- The script spends excessive time on Anna’s backstory and emotional repression, leaving limited stage time for actual cooking demonstrations.
- The songs have a Broadway heart but lack distinctive melodies, and overlapping vocal lines often obscure the lyrics.
- The ending adds a sweet surprise that incorporates Anna’s Jewish heritage, providing a culturally resonant resolution.
Why it matters: London theatre audiences and Nigella Lawson fans lose a fully satisfying culinary experience, as the production’s excess backstory and indistinct songs dilute its promised blend of grief‑healing and cooking, and the show’s promise of a magical, food‑driven transformation remains undercooked, reducing its impact as a fresh theatrical offering.
