Cammock Withdraws NPG Artwork After Churchill Famine Row
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Helen Cammock withdrew her 40-minute video installation "The Persistence" from the National Portrait Gallery on Monday at her own request, after the work had been on temporary display for 10 months
- Andrew Roberts organized a letter signed by 50 peers — including Churchill's grandson Sir Nicholas Soames — sent to the gallery's board calling the installation's description of Churchill an "ideologically motivated rant"
- The contested line in Cammock's piece compared Churchill's role in the 1943 Bengal famine, which killed an estimated 3 million people in eastern India, to Oliver Cromwell's starvation campaigns in Ireland
- The Daily Telegraph called the assertion that Churchill caused the famine "incorrect," describing the tragedy as a lethal food shortage caused by natural disasters, local mismanagement, and wartime supply problems
- Both the artist and gallery initially defended the work, but the NPG confirmed its removal at Cammock's request, saying it "respects her decision" while acknowledging "the opinions of those who were offended"
- Cammock rejected "incredible pressure on artists and arts institutions to bend to external pressure," arguing that "to question, challenge and explore ideas and histories is vital to a healthy society and art is intrinsic to this"
Why it matters: Cammock's withdrawal hands a victory to the 50 peers and the Telegraph campaign that pressured the gallery. The NPG's "artistic piece, not a documentary" framing ultimately deferred to that pressure, raising questions about how much latitude cultural institutions will defend for artists examining empire's darkest chapters.
