Raya, Neuer, Maignan: Who Is World's Best Goalkeeper?
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- David Raya made four key saves in Arsenal's 1-0 Champions League win at Sporting, including tipping Maxi Araujo's shot onto the crossbar, prompting team-mates to call him "the best in the world"
- Manuel Neuer rolled back the years at age 40 with his 136th Champions League start for Bayern Munich in a win at Real Madrid, with Peter Schmeichel calling it "one of the best games I have ever seen"
- Raya holds the most clean sheets of any goalkeeper in Europe's top-five leagues (22) across all competitions, though he was nominated for the 2025 Yashin Trophy and did not finish in the top three
- Alisson won the inaugural Yashin Trophy in 2019 and finished second in 2022 and 2025, with Liverpool boss Arne Slot declaring him "the best in the world" after his performance in Paris
- Gianluigi Donnarumma has been Manchester City's undisputed No. 1 since joining in September, winning the Yashin Trophy in 2021 and 2025, but Italy have failed to qualify for a third successive World Cup
- Neuer's Real Madrid heroics sparked German media calls for his return to international duty despite his August 2024 retirement, though Oliver Baumann is currently Germany's first choice
- Yassine Bounou and Morocco were awarded the Afcon 2025 title after Caf overturned the final result, though Senegal have appealed the decision
Why it matters: The debate carries World Cup-sized stakes: Raya dominates club stats (22 clean sheets) but is not Spain's first choice, while Donnarumma owns two Yashin Trophies yet can't drag Italy to a third straight qualifying failure. For goalkeepers, the source shows, individual awards only translate into legacy when paired with tournament-stage success — a bar Neuer and Alisson have cleared and others have not.
