Voicemails for Isabelle Director on Magic Card Twist
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- "Voicemails for Isabelle" debuted on Netflix last Friday after nearly eight years of development, with screenwriter Leah McKendrick taking over as director and reshaping the script through multiple last-minute additions.
- The scene where Wes (Nick Robinson) tries to tell Jill about the voicemails — but she's asleep on the couch when he comes out of the bathroom — was added "super last minute" during Vancouver prep after the studio pushed to show Wes "try to do the right thing."
- The Magic: The Gathering subplot, in which Wes trades an ultra-rare Black Lotus card to a hacker to retrieve Jill's lost voicemails from her late sister, was added mid-production and cleared with Wizards of the Coast "the day of, or the day before" shooting, per McKendrick.
- Nick Robinson wasn't initially sold on the Magic: The Gathering idea, asking McKendrick "Are we sure about this?" before shooting; McKendrick told him she'd built the scenes so they could be cut, but the actor ended up being "so adorable talking about Magic: The Gathering" that they kept it.
- Jill's relationship with her late sister Isabelle, who was diagnosed with cystic fibrosis as a child and dies in the film's opening minutes, is the film's true love story — expressed through years of long voicemails the sisters left each other as adults living in different cities.
- McKendrick also plays Breeda, one of Wes's best friends, explaining she wants to be "in the pool" with her actors because "it feels more real if I'm in the movie."
Why it matters: The Magic: The Gathering subplot was nearly cut — Robinson initially asked "Are we sure about this?" and clearance with Wizards of the Coast came the day before shooting — but it became the film's emotional crux, with Wes trading his rare Black Lotus to recover Jill's voicemails. For studio-driven rom-coms, the most memorable beats often arrive under deadline.
Ask SkimNews
