Newcastle and Villa's Parallel Rebuilds Hit Growing Pains — SkimNews
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Newcastle lost manager Eddie Howe in pre-season (just under five years after taking charge, 25 days before the campaign started) along with key players Sandro Tonali, Bruno Guimaraes, and Anthony Gordon, retaining just 70% of last season's league minutes — the fourth-lowest figure in the division.
- Aston Villa saw the biggest overhaul of any club, retaining only 49% of their league minutes after selling Emiliano Martinez, Lucas Digne, Ezri Konsa, Youri Tielemans, Morgan Rogers, and Ollie Watkins, with Matthias Jaissle's Newcastle and Unai Emery's Villa both struggling to find rhythm.
- Newcastle went unbeaten in their opening five matches but have since lost their last two away games by identical 4-1 scorelines — the first time since 2012 they have conceded four or more goals in back-to-back Premier League away matches — with Carragher blaming the squad's "lack of physicality" after a loss at Coventry.
- Villa started the season with a 4-0 loss at Brighton and didn't score a league goal until September 12, but responded with a 6-0 Champions League thrashing of Fenerbahce on Wednesday, with new signings Nicolas Jackson, Johan Manzambi, and Zion Suzuki all impressing.
- Both clubs lead the Premier League in errors leading to shots — Newcastle with 14, Villa with 13 — and are tied with three errors leading to goals apiece, pointing to disjointed squads still adapting to fresh faces.
- The rebuilds share a common thread of youth replacing experience: Newcastle's eight summer signings average 21.4 years old to replace the likes of Guimaraes (28) and Tonali (26), while Villa's 11 new recruits averaged 23 versus the 29-year-old average of the senior players they sold.
Why it matters: Newcastle and Villa jointly account for the two highest error counts leading to shots in the Premier League (14 and 13), reflecting squads in flux after mass summer departures. With new signings averaging 21-23 years old replacing experienced cores, both clubs are gambling that patience outweighs the pressure of immediate results.
Ask SkimNews
