Montana Commissioner Ousted After Coal Revenue Safeguards Push
Get the Energy newsletter
Daily energy & climate — solar, EVs, oil, the policy fights and tech bets shaping the transition. Free.
- Robert Pancratz, a Musselshell County commissioner and risk analyst consultant, lost the Republican primary for his seat by 26 percentage points to Mark Olson, the undersheriff of Golden Valley County.
- Pancratz had calculated the county could lose up to $11.6 million if Sen. Steve Daines's Crow Revenue Act passes; he pushed for a contingency plan to diversify revenue if coal income was disrupted, which Signal Peak Energy publicly framed as environmental activism against the mine.
- Signal Peak Energy, operator of Montana's only longwall coal mine in Roundup, exports the vast majority of its coal to Asia; CEO Parker Phipps briefed the winning candidate on the mine's fiscal relationship with the county, and the winner's cousin Alan Olson — a former state legislator and former executive director of the Montana Petroleum Association — urged him to run.
- The Crow Revenue Act would transfer federally held coal to Signal Peak through a private land swap, stripping Musselshell County of its share of federal coal royalties; Signal Peak warns that if the bill fails and it loses a federal lawsuit challenging the Trump-era 'energy emergency' that granted mine access to federal coal, the mine could shut down, eliminating all tax revenue and hundreds of jobs.
- A secretly recorded commissioner meeting — posted to a local Facebook group by a Signal Peak Energy employee less than a month before the election — captured Pancratz and two other commissioners suggesting they seek a $100 million endowment to 'scare' Daines and the company over the bill.
- Mark Olson will likely run unopposed in the general election; former commissioner Nicole Borner warned his win will 'set back' long-term economic diversification planning, leaving the county with 'a few crumbs to duct tape a few issues.'
Why it matters: A single coal operator appears to have orchestrated the ouster of a sitting commissioner who wanted fiscal safeguards — not closure — for a mine-dependent county. Musselshell now faces a binary: if the Crow Revenue Act passes as written, the county loses up to $11.6 million in annual revenue; if it fails and Signal Peak loses its federal lawsuit, the mine shuts down entirely, wiping out all tax revenue and hundreds of jobs. The result is fewer voices in the room planning for either outcome.
Ask SkimNews
