Premier League to publish full KMI Panel verdicts on referee and VAR
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Premier League will publish full KMI Panel judgements on referee and VAR decisions for the first time this season, expanding transparency beyond the prior general summaries on its Match Centre account.
- KMI Panel — five members (three former players/coaches plus representatives from the Premier League and PGM0) — has met since 2022-23 but kept verdicts private, though clubs routinely leaked them.
- Last season saw 25 VAR errors identified by the panel, up from 18 the previous year, but still below 31 in 2023-24 and 38 in 2022-23; errors factor into performance-related payments to referees.
- KMI Panel operates by simple majority and recognizes that the VAR's higher "clear and obvious" threshold means an on-field error can coexist with a correct VAR non-intervention, and it also reviews non-reviewable situations like missed second yellow cards.
- Premier League is rolling out RefCam broadcast audio of referees speaking to players — used one or two times per fixture round but not live — while continuing Ifab talks to eventually share VAR communications publicly.
- Selected direct quotes from referees and VAR officials explaining their real-time reasoning will appear on the Premier League's X account, website, and app, replacing the previous generalized incident summaries.
Why it matters: Fans and clubs will now see exactly how the Premier League grades every major officiating call, putting public pressure on the 25 errors logged last season and linking those grades directly to referees' end-of-season pay — while Ifab rules still block live VAR audio from being broadcast.
Ask SkimNews
