How Emmy-Nominated Shows Cast Their Breakout Performers
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Cathy Gelfond and Erica Berger cast 250 performers with at least one line on "The Pitt" Season 2, with 13 earning Emmy recognition — up 10 from the show's first season — since the show's unique filming style provides L.A. locals up to six months of consistent background work.
- Allison Jones and Emily Buntyn cast "Widow's Bay" with intentionally non-glamorous locals to match its New England island setting, signing Dale Dickey via an audition consisting solely of a coughing fit (they needed an actual smoker) and recruiting Kate O'Flynn directly from London for her first Emmy nomination.
- "Hacks" casting directors Linda Lowy and Morgan Smith cast more L.A.-based talent for the show's fifth and final season partly because budget pressures left "no extra money anymore," and Smith said breakdowns now "literally" specify prioritizing queer performers for queer roles.
- Sharon Bialy, Sherry Thomas and Russell Scott — all veterans of "Breaking Bad" and "Better Call Saul" — cast Vince Gilligan's "Pluribus" by flipping through old handwritten audition books to find Karolina Wydra (who had no agent at the time) and chatting with Carlos Manuel Vesga for an hour at Gelson's before casting him as Manousos.
- "Hacks" brought back Laurie Metcalf and Lauren Weedman for its final season while adding Cherry Jones — after months of "gentle, creative" negotiation around her Emmy schedule — and Leslie Bibb to the "Montecito" episode.
- Bialy said Gilligan's casting philosophy favors "really smart" theater-trained actors who've never been on camera, requiring long pre-production conversations to explain that "it's just about listening."
Why it matters: Casting decisions for this year's Emmy-nominated shows reveal how unconventional searches — handwritten audition books, a Gelson's parking lot conversation, an audition built around a single coughing fit — can surface first-time nominees that traditional pipelines miss. Linda Lowy's blunt observation that "there's no extra money anymore" also signals a TV-budget reality forcing L.A.-local casting over expensive out-of-town imports, which quietly reshapes where working actors find their breaks.
Ask SkimNews
