'Mustache' Review: Khan's Pakistani American Debut — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- "Mustache" marks the debut feature of writer-director Imran J. Khan, a bilingual coming-of-age comedy set in the mid-'90s Bay Area following 13-year-old Pakistani American Ilyas, pulled from a San Jose Islamic school by his struggling immigrant father and dropped into public high school.
- Atharv Verma anchors the film in his feature debut as Ilyas, delivering what the review calls a 'delicate' performance built around flowery voiceover, schematic diagrams, and visual close-ups of his mustache bristles — the film opens with the religious question of whether he's allowed to shave them.
- Alicia Silverstone plays Miss Martin, the kind drama teacher whose class Ilyas joins after following classmate Liz Park (Melody Cao), only to develop real feelings for her as his scheme to get re-transferred backfires.
- The film's central deception plot echoes "Dear Evan Hansen" — described in the review as a 'less perverse' version — with Yasmeen (Ayana Manji), Ilyas's Islamic-school crush, writing him fake emails from a fictional girlfriend he hopes his parents will stumble upon on the family computer.
- Rizwan Manji plays Hameed, the immigrant father who pulls Ilyas out of Islamic school amid struggles with his new business and five mouths to feed; the film's tension hinges on whether Ilyas's web of untruths will expose him as devastatingly as being fully seen by his peers.
- The review praises Khan's careful direction and reaction shots but notes the film eventually loses steam, framing its subversion of coming-of-age genre conventions as a side effect of using Ilyas's outsider status as an aesthetic North Star.
Why it matters: This debut gives the coming-of-age genre one of the few Pakistani American lenses on its outsider tropes: Khan uses the mid-'90s Bay Area Islamic-to-public-school transfer to turn a fish-out-of-water setup into a culturally specific, anxiety-saturated comedy, and the Variety review frames it as an auteur subverting genre expectations rather than recreating them.
Ask SkimNews
