Turtletaub's 'Borges and Me' Favors Charm Over Poetry
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Marc Turtletaub directs a screen adaptation of Jay Parini’s 2020 memoir 'Borges and Me', transforming a literary anecdote into a gently sentimental road movie
- Luis Gnecco plays José Luis Borges as a lively, talkative figure full of impish wisdom and childlike wonder, emphasizing character over historical precision
- Fionn Whitehead portrays the young Jay Parini as an earnest, unworldly American student overwhelmed by his responsibility to guide the sightless writer
- Christopher Norr captures the Scottish Highlands with dewy autumnal crispness, making the landscape a textured backdrop that enhances the film’s mellow tone
- Oren Moverman co-writes the screenplay, balancing poetic moments with simpler feelgood sentiment, ultimately favoring warmth over deep literary engagement
- Alan Cumming appears as poet Alastair Reid, who sets the journey in motion by leaving Parini alone with Borges during a last-minute trip to London
Why it matters: The film prioritizes nostalgic charm and emotional accessibility over rigorous literary analysis, which may appeal to arthouse audiences but sidelines Borges’ complex legacy. This shift benefits broader viewership but risks reducing a profound writer to a whimsical caricature for festival-friendly storytelling.
Ask SkimNews
