Webb Backs VAR Standing by Botman Yellow on Jackson — SkimNews
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Howard Webb called Botman's foul on Jackson a "high-end reckless challenge" but said the on-field yellow card stood because VAR Stuart Attwell found no scissor action and no stud contact, conditions that would have triggered intervention.
- Referee Jarred Gillett showed the yellow in real time, ruling the tackle reckless despite Botman getting a touch on the ball, with Webb noting the decision would have stood even had Gillett shown red.
- Nicolas Jackson said post-match that the tackle "nearly broke my leg" and hoped "maybe next time a red card," suggesting he felt the sanction was too lenient.
- Villa won the match 1-0 through Johan Manzambi's 36th-minute goal, the result standing despite the contentious early challenge.
- VAR intervention volume has surged this season — 21 interventions through seven rounds, nine subjective, versus just three (zero subjective) at the same point last year, yet Webb said mistakes are "markedly down" relative to total interventions.
- The Premier League Key Match Incidents Panel judged only one VAR intervention wrong so far this season — Man City's offside winning goal at Manchester United — with one missed penalty awarded to Arsenal at Aston Villa, compared to four errors after seven rounds last season.
Why it matters: Webb's defense arrives as VAR intervention rates have roughly sextupled versus last season (21 vs 3), yet the Premier League's own panel has logged only one intervention error through seven rounds, down from four at the same point a year ago — a lighter-touch philosophy that is reshaping how aggressively VAR steps in on subjective calls.
Ask SkimNews
