Brown Argus Blocks Gresham House's £12m Tree Farm
Get the Energy newsletter
Daily energy & climate — solar, EVs, oil, the policy fights and tech bets shaping the transition. Free.
- Gresham House bought Todrig, a 580-hectare border moorland, for £12m in 2022 and plans to develop it into a commercial tree farm, but the project has been halted pending further ecological checks due to the presence of the northern brown argus butterfly.
- Northern brown argus — a butterfly with 'vulnerable' status — has become a key obstacle to the forestry project at Todrig, prompting a legal challenge that forced regulators to conduct additional environmental assessments.
- David Lintott, through his company Restore Nature, led the legal campaign against the plantation, arguing that Sitka spruce monocultures severely harm biodiversity compared to native grasslands and calcareous habitats.
- Rachel Reeves excluded woodland from recent inheritance tax reforms, preserving a loophole that allows commercial forests to qualify for business property relief after just two years, enabling wealthy families to save millions in taxes.
- Camilla Fowler, chair of the local community council, opposes the plantation, stating that such forestry scars the landscape and replaces rich ecosystems with dark, monocultural tree blocks.
- Apithanny Bourne of Butterfly Conservation notes that inflated land values driven by forestry grants pressure farmers to sell, even if they prefer regenerative agriculture, as prices now reach four to five times prior levels.
Why it matters: Wealthy investors are exploiting a tax loophole to convert ecologically sensitive UK grasslands into commercial forests, threatening rare species and long-term biodiversity. The Todrig case reveals how inheritance tax incentives—untouched by recent reforms—can override local conservation goals, with land values inflated by grants enabling large-scale habitat loss that may take centuries to reverse.
