Fantasy Football: Drafting Winners from the No. 8 Pick
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Christian McCaffrey was the first pick at 1.8, paired with Rashee Rice at 2.5, following a strategy of balancing one RB and one WR in the opening rounds of a 12-team PPR league.
- Josh Jacobs (3.8), Malik Nabers (4.5), and Lamar Jackson (5.8) rounded out the first five rounds, with the author calling the first four picks 'unbelievably risky' — a 30-year-old injury-prone RB, two WRs recovering from knee injuries, and an RB with off-field allegations.
- Lamar Jackson was named the favorite pick, having averaged 30 points per game as the 2024 fantasy QB leader and scored 33+ points in 4 of his first 5 starts; his Round 5 fall let the author skip tight end Colston Loveland in Round 3.
- Malik Nabers is identified as the make-or-break player after tearing his ACL and meniscus, with the author citing Jordy Nelson, Keenan Allen, Cooper Kupp, and Chris Godwin as WRs who had big seasons after ACL tears.
- Davante Adams, DJ Moore, and Mike Evans are cited as the dependable WRs the author wanted, arguing that No. 8 drafters should use two of their first four picks on receivers since that tier won't last to Round 5.
- The author named David Montgomery (6.5) as a borderline-regret pick, noting Harold Fannin Jr. was available at the same spot and could have strengthened the tight end position.
Why it matters: Fantasy drafters at the No. 8 pick in 12-team PPR leagues face a structural problem around securing two top-26 WRs, and this guide demonstrates a worked solution — lean into the upside of injury-risk players like McCaffrey, Rice, and Nabers rather than reach for safe options in Rounds 3-4. The author openly flags the roster as a gamble, making the strategy as much a philosophy on risk-vs-floor as a specific cheat sheet.
