Disclosure Day Gets B CinemaScore, Critic Pans Plot
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- CinemaScore graded Disclosure Day a B, the joint second-worst grade of any Spielberg film, tied with Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny and ahead only of AI: Artificial Intelligence, which received a C
- Disclosure Day centers on first contact arriving not through a five-note call-and-response but through Emily Blunt's weathergirl, who speaks in tongues after absorbing social media, multiple languages and a century of cover-ups in a single download
- David Koepp wrote the script, extending his run of deception-themed thrillers after Black Bag (2024) for Steven Soderbergh and scripts for Bridge of Spies and The Post
- The cast features Emily Blunt, Wyatt Russell and Colman Domingo, though the reviewer judged them 'cardboard-cutout heroes and villains' lacking the 'flesh-and-blood' depth of Roy Neary or Elliott
- John Williams composed the score and Janusz Kamiński shot the film, but the reviewer found the VFX unconvincing, asking how 'a film-maker who once had us believing in dinosaurs should now struggle to conjure believable woodland creatures'
- The film builds toward Blunt's character declaring 'listen' as a prescription for social division, which the reviewer reads as Spielberg's director-stand-in message but describes as 'defensive' rather than substantive
Why it matters: For a filmmaker whose career has been built on audience consensus — from Close Encounters to The Fabelmans — a B CinemaScore tied for his second-worst opening signals a rare break with his fanbase, and the reviewer's reading of 'Disclosure Day' as nostalgic 20th-century moralising (trust family, local news and organised religion) suggests the film has failed to convert its social-division theme into a message that lands with contemporary audiences.
