ESPN Ranks College Football's All-Time Supervillains
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Caleb Williams made a record-setting NIL deal after transferring from Oklahoma to USC to follow Lincoln Riley, starred in national TV ads during his own games, won the 2022 Heisman, and was widely mocked when he cried in his mother's arms after USC's 2023 title-contention exit.
- Deion Sanders is the only entry with two villain eras — taunting Clemson at Death Valley in 1988 as a Florida State player, then nearly 'breaking the internet every Saturday' as Colorado's head coach after moving from Jackson State in 2023.
- The 1990 Miami Hurricanes committed 15 penalties for 202 yards in a 46-3 Cotton Bowl rout of Texas, a performance that directly inspired the NCAA to institute 15-yard penalties for excessive celebration.
- Brian Bosworth ('The Boz') wore a homemade T-shirt redefining 'NCAA' as 'National Communists Against Athletes' at the 1987 Orange Bowl after failing an NCAA steroid test, which led to his dismissal from Oklahoma.
- Johnny Manziel became the first freshman to win the Heisman Trophy at Texas A&M, with his post-Cotton Bowl nightclub celebration (Roman candle, Dom Perignon) becoming a lead TMZ story in 2013.
- Tim Tebow divided Florida's fan base from his 2006 arrival over whether he should supplant national-title-winning QB Chris Leak, and the author cites 'Tebow Fatigue' in the press box as costing him a second Heisman.
- ESPN appears at No. 7 as a self-aware joke entry, with the author recounting being pelted with rocks in Knoxville in 1997 and a Crown Royal bottle in Columbus years later while wearing an ESPN jacket.
Why it matters: The list functions as a cultural time capsule of college football's most polarizing figures, with the 1990 Miami Hurricanes entry providing the rare concrete policy consequence — their 15-penalty Cotton Bowl spectacle directly produced a specific NCAA rule change that still governs in-game celebrations today. The piece also highlights how the definition of 'villain' has shifted: Bosworth's anti-establishment act would be celebrated today, while Caleb Williams' NIL-era behavior draws the same boos.
