Most controversial finishes in college football history: Revisiting wild endings on heels of Michigan-WMU — SkimNews
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- No. 16 Michigan beat Western Michigan 13-12 in a chaotic 2026 season opener, reopening a long conversation about controversial endings in college football history
- Michigan State beat Michigan 26-24 in 2001 after home timekeeper Bob "Spartan Bob" Stehlin stopped the clock at one second, allowing Jeff Smoker's TD pass and costing the Wolverines a Rose Bowl trip and Big Ten title tiebreaker with Illinois
- Texas edged Nebraska 13-12 in the 2009 Big 12 Championship after officials placed one second back on the clock; Hunter Lawrence's 46-yard field goal sent the Longhorns to the BCS title game, where they lost to Alabama 37-21
- Central Michigan stunned Oklahoma State in 2016 on an untimed down after a late intentional grounding flag; the source notes a "loss of down" rule exception should have ended the game, and the Chippewas converted a desperate lateral sequence into a game-winning touchdown
- Cal beat Stanford 25-20 in 1982 on "The Play" — five laterals after the clock expired, ending with Kevin Moen crashing into a Stanford trombone player in the end zone
- Miami survived Virginia Tech 38-34 in 2024 after Virginia Tech's Hail Mary catch was ruled a touchdown on the field then reversed on review; the ACC cited a Miami player touching the ball while out of bounds
- Ohio State beat Michigan 30-27 in double overtime in 2016 after J.T. Barrett's fourth-down spot was upheld on review; Jim Harbaugh was fined $10,000 by the Big Ten for blasting officials in his postgame press conference
Why it matters: Three of eight cited controversies involve Michigan, including the 2001 clock incident that cost the Wolverines a Rose Bowl and the 2016 'The Spot' call that extended a long losing streak vs. Ohio State. The roundup frames officiating errors and clock malfunctions as recurring, championship-altering forces — not isolated flukes.
Ask SkimNews
