NCAA Issues New Clock Protocol After Michigan's Controversial Win — SkimNews
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- NCAA national coordinator of officials Ron Snodgrass issued a memo, approved by secretary rules editor Matt Young, requiring replay officials to use the embedded game clock in the program feed (or the broadcast clock graphic if no embedded clock is available) when adjusting time during reviews, rather than the in-stadium game clock
- Had that protocol been in place Saturday, Michigan would not have been awarded an extra play and Western Michigan would have won 12-7 instead of losing 13-12, based on the NBC broadcast clock
- On what appeared to be the final snap, Bryce Underwood's Hail Mary was intercepted by Micah Davis, but replays showed the clock at zero with the ball still airborne; Big Ten replay officials restored one second, and JJ Buchanan caught the second attempt for a 47-yard winning touchdown
- MAC commissioner Jon A. Steinbrecher reversed his Sunday defense of the process and asked the NCAA to overturn the result and have the College Football Playoff selection committee recognize Western Michigan as the "actual winner"
- NCAA told ESPN its rules contain no mechanism to overturn a game's outcome and the FBS oversight committee "does not have the authority" to reverse results, citing Articles 3 and 9 of the rulebook, which bar rule changes after periods end
- The CFP said it received the MAC appeal letter and is reviewing; the Big Ten stood by its original Saturday statement, while Michigan told ESPN the conference "handles all replay reviews and discussion"
- Michigan dropped out of the AP Top 25 after entering the season ranked No. 16 and hosts No. 11 Oklahoma on Saturday; Western Michigan plays Monmouth at home
Why it matters: The new NCAA memo implicitly confirms Big Ten replay officials violated protocol by one second — enough to flip a one-point game — yet the governing body has stated it cannot overturn the result, leaving Western Michigan without an on-field remedy while the CFP independently reviews whether to adjust its own deliberations around the outcome.
Ask SkimNews
