FBS Committee Can't Overturn WMU Loss Despite Improper Replay Protocols — SkimNews
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- The NCAA's FBS oversight committee said it "does not have the authority" to overturn the result of Western Michigan's 13-12 loss to Michigan on Sept. 5, despite concluding that instant replay protocols "were not followed" and that the game's "outcome would have been different" had they been.
- Michigan won on a Hail Mary touchdown pass from quarterback Bryce Underwood after Big Ten replay officials restored one second to the clock, even though the NBC broadcast graphic showed zeros before Underwood's first attempt was touched outside the back of the end zone.
- MAC commissioner Jon A. Steinbrecher wrote to the NCAA and College Football Playoff on Sept. 8 calling the result "directly affected by a replay officiating error resulting from the failure to follow an established and specific protocol" and asked that Western Michigan be declared the "actual winner."
- The NCAA responded by issuing new standard timing guidance in a memo from national coordinator of officials Ron Snodgrass, approved by secretary rules editor Matt Young: the official time for all college football games is the in-stadium game clock, and replay reviews must rely on the embedded game clock from the program feed.
- Michigan (2-0) has moved on after defeating Oklahoma last weekend, while Western Michigan (1-1) bounced back with a 49-14 win over Monmouth — though the MAC champion remains denied what its commissioner calls a rightful victory.
- Western Michigan was seeking its first-ever win over the Wolverines; the MAC's formal protest went unredressed, but the NCAA's new memo now standardizes timing protocol across every college football game site going forward.
Why it matters: The committee's split verdict — acknowledging a blown call but refusing to reverse it — left Western Michigan's grievance unredressed while forcing the NCAA to fix the process instead of the result. The new Snodgrass memo gives every replay booth in college football a uniform rule (use the in-stadium clock) that didn't exist on Sept. 5, meaning the exact scenario that decided the WMU-Michigan game now has a codified answer for every future contest.
Ask SkimNews
