Ellis’s 'The Shards' Novel Loses Its Voice in Murphy Adaptation — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Bret Easton Ellis published The Shards in 2023 as an autofictional memoir-novel blending regret, shame, and self-reckoning from middle age, centered on his teenage years while drafting Less Than Zero.
- Ryan Murphy adapted The Shards for FX, removing the novel’s first-person, time-distanced narration and replacing it with a near-future voiceover by the younger Bret, weakening the metafictional depth.
- The FX series departs drastically from the book after the first two episodes—co-written by Ellis—after which he was sidelined in a reported power struggle and stopped promoting the show.
- Murphy’s adaptation adds tonally inconsistent plotlines including a American Bandstand–style dance competition, a Shakespearean-costume monologue episode, and a kidnapping subplot involving a classmate with Tourette’s-like outbursts.
- Igby Rigney, who plays young Bret, narrates the series with sneering commentary like 'Kids today have it fucking easy,' new writing not present in Ellis’s original text.
- Richard Gere’s son Homer Gere plays the enigmatic Robert, suspected of being the Trawler serial killer, while Cindy Crawford’s daughter Kaia Gerber plays Susan, Bret’s object of affection.
Why it matters: Writers lose control when adaptations prioritize spectacle over interiority: Ellis’s late-career act of literary self-excavation becomes, in Murphy’s hands, a campy ’80s nostalgia vehicle. The shift from introspection to surface undermines the novel’s hard-won vulnerability, risking its legacy for TV shock value.
Ask SkimNews
