FX's The Shards Loses the Book's Voice — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- FX adapted Bret Easton Ellis's 2023 novel "The Shards" into a TV series with Ryan Murphy as showrunner; Murphy said at the launch party, "I knew the songs, I knew the clothes, I knew everything because I had lived it. It was my time."
- Bret Easton Ellis co-wrote the first two episodes before being sidelined in a reported power struggle, and he has neither promoted the series on his personal Instagram nor appeared at its glitzy July launch party.
- The adaptation eliminates the novel's metafictional frame — an older, regretful Ellis narrating his teenage self with forty years of hindsight — replacing it with voiceover from the teenage Bret (Igby Rigney) speaking from a "vague near future."
- The show adds several plotlines absent from the 594-page novel, including an American Bandstand-style dance competition, a kidnapping subplot involving a foulmouthed classmate with Tourette's-like symptoms, and a costume episode of Shakespearean monologues.
- Homer Gere and Kaia Gerber — the respective children of Richard Gere and Cindy Crawford — play the enigmatic transfer student Robert and Susan, the prom-queen object of Bret's desire; Jordan Roth plays Terry's (Wes Bentley) machinating assistant Steven.
Why it matters: The Shards misfire illustrates how an autofictional novel whose entire emotional architecture depends on a backward-looking, self-indicting narrator collapses when transplanted into a visual medium that prizes surfaces; the sidelining of co-writer Ellis — who skipped his own show's launch — signals a creative-control dispute behind one of FX's fall tentpoles, and a 594-page book of regret gets repackaged as '80s nostalgia pageantry.
Ask SkimNews
