Ryan Murphy's The Shards Loses the Novel's Heart — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Bret Easton Ellis co-wrote the first two episodes of FX's "The Shards" adaptation before being sidelined in a reported power struggle, and has neither promoted the show on Instagram nor appeared at the July launch party.
- Ryan Murphy's show eliminates the novel's metafictional framing device: the older, regretful middle-aged Bret who narrates from a distance, replacing it with young Bret (Igby Rigney) narrating from a vague near future.
- The Shards novel, published in 2023, runs 594 pages and is an autofictional murder mystery set in 1980s Sherman Oaks, with teenage Bret working on an early draft of "Less Than Zero" while suspecting a classmate of being a serial killer.
- The FX adaptation adds original storylines absent from the book, including a dance competition on an American Bandstand–style TV show, a kidnapping plot involving a classmate with apparent Tourette's, and an episode with characters speaking in Shakespearean verse.
- Murphy framed the project as personal, saying at the launch party, "I knew the songs, I knew the clothes, I knew everything because I had lived it. It was my time" — a stance the reviewer argues treats Ellis's explicitly personal novel as Murphy's own story.
- The cast includes Igby Rigney as Bret, Homer Gere as the mysterious transfer student Robert, Kaia Gerber as Susan, Hayes Warner as Debbie, Graham Campbell as Thom, Wes Bentley as the producer Terry, and Jordan Roth as Steven.
- The novel's animating sentiments of regret and shame about closeted sexuality and lost teenage friendships are replaced by what the review calls blustery, nostalgic '80s aesthetics — "Weren't the '80s crazy?" — at the cost of the book's interiority.
Why it matters: Ellis wrote "The Shards" to dismantle his own mythos from the inside, admitting that "Less Than Zero" was an act of mimicry — making the adaptation's choice to re-canonize that mythology as shallow provocation especially pointed. The reported power struggle that sidelined Ellis mid-production signals a creative mismatch between source author and showrunner, and Murphy's pivot from inner life to external '80s gloss turns a 594-page interior novel into surface-level nostalgia television.
Ask SkimNews
