Mermaid Beach Review: Mermaidcore Undone by Nylon Tail
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Mermaid Beach is a family film set on the Welsh coastline about a teenager named Lily who transforms into a mermaid after finding a shell on the beach.
- The film's mermaid tail is made of nylon that becomes clingy when wet, revealing Lily's legs beneath the scales — the reviewer called the transformation unconvincing and said the film 'falls at the first hurdle.'
- Ellie Bindman plays Lily, a London teen resentful about relocating to the Welsh seaside for her stepdad's work; Jack Taruschio Thomas plays Shane, an awkward trainee reporter chasing a mermaid-sighting lead.
- The story carries an eco-message about ocean pollution tied to a textiles factory where Lily's stepdad Jason (Andrew Rolfe) works, with the factory owner and town mayor cast as bland, suited villains.
- The reviewer noted too many scenes of adults doing 'boring adult things in boring offices,' describing some performances as wooden enough to carve into boats.
- The verdict suggests Mermaid Beach would need substantial writing and characterization work — and a better tail — before it could function as a film or a potential children's TV series.
Why it matters: For a 'mermaidcore' family film, the unconvincing nylon tail undermines the central fantasy that drives the story. The eco-message about ocean pollution tied to local industry gives the film a stated thematic spine, but the reviewer argues thin characterization and stilted adult performances leave it better suited to a children's TV series than a standalone movie.
Ask SkimNews
