Aims rejects News Corp's 'reef refusing to die' claim
Get the Energy newsletter
Daily energy & climate — solar, EVs, oil, the policy fights and tech bets shaping the transition. Free.
- The Australian newspaper claimed official data showed the Great Barrier Reef was 'refusing to die,' and an editorial dismissed climate change as a 'pseudo-religion' contradicting physics, leaning heavily on long-term monitoring showing coral cover at 'near record levels.'
- The Australian Institute of Marine Science (Aims) rejected the framing as 'oversimplified,' saying the surveys do not contradict climate warnings and that 'continued good health' overlooks 15 years of rapid gains followed by sharp losses that signal 'ecosystem instability.'
- Aims said the 2016 and 2017 bleaching events caused 'serious coral mortality at very large scales' and the 2024 event drove the reef's largest coral loss in nearly 40 years of monitoring in two of three regions — facts The Australian's report did not foreground.
- Dr Mark Eakin, a US-based oceanographer cited in The Australian, said rapid colonisation by 'weedy, fast-growing corals' is only the first recovery step, full recovery 'takes decades,' and five severe marine heatwaves hit the reef in less than a decade — leaving insufficient recovery time.
- Dr Stacy Jupiter, co-author of a Macquarie University study referenced by The Australian, said the paper was 'misinterpreted' — it was pre-designed to select 30% of reefs per ecoregion to match global 30x30 ocean protection targets, not to certify them as resilient.
- Dr Peter Ridd, a climate science sceptic quoted prominently by The Australian, said recent bleaching events had 'not produced a major drop in coral cover' — a claim Aims explicitly rejected as wrong.
Why it matters: Aims and three independent researchers rebutted The Australian's specific claims, noting that current coral cover masks serious recent mortality events. The dispute matters because coral recovery between disturbances is not the same as resilience to more frequent marine heatwaves, and the reef's future hinges on whether recovery windows stay long enough.
Ask SkimNews
