You're Killing Me review: Shields crime caper called thin — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- You're Killing Me is a six-part comedy drama starring Brooke Shields as cosy mystery novelist Allison Chandler in the fictional town of Founder's Cove, Maine, with explicit Murder, She Wrote framing.
- Shields's Allison investigates the suspected murder of sleazebag pal Nash Gilbert (Matthew MacFadzean) alongside young true crime podcaster Andi, after Gilbert falls from a balcony initially ruled a suicide.
- Tom Cavanagh plays county detective Jack Kerrigan in a weekly-murder format that includes an adulterated EpiPen at a wedding and a hot-tub electrocution as cases-of-the-week.
- The review calls the show 'thin, lazy and so disappointing,' criticizing its boomer-vs-Gen Z clichés, formulaic plot contrivances, and Shields being 'thrown back on shrillness' rather than the comedy she is capable of.
- Williamson's Andi is written mostly as an arrogant brat 'with nowhere really to take her,' the reviewer argues, though both leads are credited with more talent than the script affords.
- The series has been commissioned for a second season; the reviewer greets the news with 'hope rather than despair,' wanting it to become the Gilmore Girls-inflected homage it briefly promised in the pilot.
Why it matters: A streamer greenlighting a second season despite this pan signals confidence in audience appetite or Shields's draw beyond critical reception. For Shields, the role marks a return to leading TV work at age 61, where the goodwill she built on Friends and Suddenly Susan is doing more heavy lifting than the material itself.
Ask SkimNews
