Queen at Sea Review: Hammer Returns With Dementia Drama — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Lance Hammer directs Queen at Sea, his first feature since winning Sundance in 2008 with Ballast, marking what the reviewer calls "an almighty comeback"
- Tom Courtenay and Anna Calder-Marshall star as Martin and Leslie, an elderly couple whose ongoing sexual relationship becomes the centre of the film's dilemma after Leslie's dementia diagnosis
- Juliette Binoche plays Amanda, Leslie's daughter, who walks in on her mother and stepfather having sex and calls the police on Martin for rape — a decision she nearly instantly regrets
- Martin defends the relationship by arguing that marital sex comforts dementia patients just like the food, shelter, and medical care already provided without meaningful consent — a parallel the GP had reportedly advised against
- The police intervention forces Leslie into a care home as the only way to suspend legal action, an outcome Martin furiously resists as a "permanent stain on his character" and as a malicious tactic by Amanda
- The film culminates in a four-way conversation between a social worker, Amanda, Martin, and Leslie, in which Martin tearfully reaffirms his wedding vows and Leslie poignantly returns them — leaving their legal and moral weight deliberately unresolved
- Reviewer compares the film to Michael Haneke's Amour and Gaspar Noé's Vortex, praising its "tragic, wintry candour" and an "enigmatic final sequence refusing the traditional final cadence"
Why it matters: Hammer joins a sparse, high-prestige tradition (Amour, Vortex) of refusing to flinch from dementia's most uncomfortable questions. By refusing to adjudicate whether Martin is an abuser or a loving husband, the film dramatises a dilemma that families, GPs, and care homes confront in real life — and for which the law currently has no clean answer.
Ask SkimNews
