Verity Review Slams Third Act as Substandard — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- Verity is adapted by screenwriter Nick Antosca from Colleen Hoover's novel, with Dakota Johnson as Lowen, a struggling writer hired to secretly ghostwrite the remaining novels for mega-bestselling author Verity Crawford.
- Anne Hathaway plays Verity Crawford, a best-selling author now immobile in a wheelchair and unable to speak, while Josh Hartnett plays her handsome, sensitive husband Jeremy at their secluded Vermont lakeside home.
- The Guardian review criticizes the film's third act as 'disintegrat[ing] into a shower of small substandard plot points,' despite what it calls a 'sensational opening sequence.'
- The reviewer flags structural holes including Lowen never asking anyone how Verity became incapacitated, and notes the sinister nurse (Irina Dvorovenko) 'simply and bafflingly disappears' from the story.
- The film's narrative rests on Lowen finding 'not one but two manuscripts' and ends with what the reviewer calls a 'lamely unresolved situation' passed off as 'fascinatingly ambiguous' — a verdict the review says 'needed a new draft.'
- Dakota Johnson returns to 'Fifty Shades' ingenue-cute territory in this erotic mystery-thriller, which the reviewer situates alongside cheeky hints of Daphne du Maurier and Brian De Palma.
Why it matters: A Colleen Hoover adaptation reuniting Dakota Johnson with the erotic-thriller genre fumbles its payoff in this review — a nurse vanishes, the protagonist asks no questions, and the ending lands as 'lamely unresolved.' The verdict undercuts what the reviewer himself acknowledges is audience demand for exactly this kind of film, suggesting the star-powered cast couldn't rescue a script that needed another pass.
Ask SkimNews
