Experts: Trump Lost Iran War, Has No Leverage
Get the Geopolitics newsletter
Daily geopolitics — wars, elections, sanctions, the diplomatic moves that move markets. Free.
- John Mearsheimer (University of Chicago) told Tom Switzer that Trump 'lost the war,' calling it 'a devastating defeat for the United States' with no solution to regain leverage over Iran.
- Mearsheimer explained that Trump's threats to escalate ring hollow because he is 'out of munitions' and Gulf allies have told him escalation is unacceptable, given Iran's threats to destroy oil facilities and desalination plants.
- Vali Nasr (Johns Hopkins SAIS) said Iran is 'in the driver's seat' and 'very comfortable demanding' concessions from the US, arguing 'the period where you can basically pressure Iran into submission... is gone.'
- Nasr added that Iran is 'not overplaying its hand' — 'It's just playing its hand' — and that much of Washington's foreign policy establishment has not yet absorbed this reality.
- Daniel DePetris (Defense Priorities) wrote that the US has little choice but to accept Iran charging transit fees for ships through the Strait of Hormuz, a situation he called inevitable.
- DePetris attributed the outcome to Trump launching his 'unprovoked war without authorization from the US Congress more than five months ago,' writing that 'Trump's war handed Iran the perfect excuse to leverage its geography' and turn the strait into a strategic card.
Why it matters: Trump launched an unprovoked war without Congressional authorization over five months ago, and now faces a strategic reversal where Iran controls the Strait of Hormuz chokepoint and can dictate terms. With US munitions depleted and Gulf allies refusing to support escalation, the US has effectively lost leverage — Iran is now positioned to charge transit fees through waters it has almost entirely shut down.
Ask SkimNews
