Fantasy baseball catcher preview for 2027: Gabriel Moreno rises as Cal Raleigh looks to rebound — SkimNews
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Gabriel Moreno (Diamondbacks) was the breakout of 2026, finishing at .311/.72/16/83/6 and the only catcher to post an .800+ OPS in both halves — improving from .822 in the first half to .927 after the break with 10 second-half homers.
- Ben Rice (Yankees) authored the position's biggest breakout, hitting .264/105/41/97/3, but is expected to lose catcher eligibility for 2027, likely making this his career-best fantasy season.
- Cal Raleigh (Mariners) was the biggest bust, hitting below the Mendoza Line in four of six months and finishing with roughly one-third of his 2025 homer total, though a 12-homer August-September surge may signal a bounce-back toward his pre-2025 level.
- Dillon Dingler (Tigers) finished with 27 HR and 91 RBI but faded down the stretch; despite going from the 20th catcher drafted on average to a likely top-six pick in 2027, the analyst projects he won't reach that ceiling again.
- Leo Bernal (Cardinals) seized St. Louis's catching job down the stretch, hitting .284/.333/.474 with 20-plus homer upside, and is so highly regarded that top prospect Rainiel Rodriguez will take third-base reps this offseason.
- Adley Rutschman (Red Sox) delivered another injury-marred underwhelming season and, entering age 29, has not been a must-start fantasy catcher since 2023, prompting the analyst to say they've stopped giving him benefit of the doubt.
Why it matters: Fantasy managers entering 2027 drafts face a materially deeper catcher pool: the $20+ tier on the FanGraphs Player Rater jumped from four players in 2025 to nine in 2026, giving drafters real top-end options beyond Cal Raleigh — who himself should bounce back but is no longer the consensus No. 1.
Ask SkimNews
