John Early Premieres 'Maddie's Secret' at TIFF
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- John Early's "Maddie's Secret" premiered as the Discovery section opener at TIFF 2025, with Magnolia Pictures set to release it at NYC's IFC Center on June 19 and in Los Angeles on June 26.
- Early deliberately kept production secretive, refusing behind-the-scenes photos to preserve the "illusion of Maddie" and the "old Hollywood glow" achieved with vintage lenses shot in his house and Kate Berlant's car.
- The film casts Early as Maddie, a budding food influencer, alongside Kate Berlant, Conner O'Malley, and Vanessa Bayer; its influences range from Sirkian melodramas and TV movies of the week like "Death of a Cheerleader" to "Red Shoe Diaries."
- Early identified a shift in his algorithm from naturalistic Bon Appétit-style content to a "sinister, sexual" style — low "blowjob angle" cameras, meat-smacking, ASMR — which he frames as an expression of sexual repression.
- The film approaches bulimia metaphorically rather than as a direct medical story, with Early describing the act of purging as "a kind of expression of that repression" mirrored in the binge-scroll cycle.
- Early traced his own entry into "Girl World" to a fifth-grade decision to befriend girls rather than risk bullying from boys, calling it "the best choice I ever made."
Why it matters: Early's "off-the-grid" approach — refusing to court financiers, leak set photos, or post before release — produced a debut that doubles as a pointed critique of algorithmically driven sexualization, a Sirkian-inflected feature with an all-alt-comedy ensemble marks Early's evolution from sketch performer to filmmaker on his own terms.
