The Dropout and You Can See Everything Probe Holmes — SkimNews
Get the Culture newsletter
Daily culture — film, music, books, the trends and ideas worth your attention. Free.
- The Dropout gives Amanda Seyfried a heightened 17-year-old Elizabeth Holmes who dances to “I'm in a Hurry (And Don't Know Why)” before a Steve Jobs poster, dramatizing the persona Holmes constructs for the world.
- You Can See Everything uses filmmakers Nathan Fielder and Lance Oppenheim's unprecedented access to Holmes to test whether she is a master manipulator or so convinced of her genius that she cannot distinguish fiction from fact, leaving the answer pointedly torn.
- The Dropout extends beyond Holmes to Stephen Fry's Ian Gibbons, the chief scientist she betrays, fires, rehires and betrays again, and to Theranos executives motivated by both the product's alleged altruism and their own Silicon Valley FOMO.
- Theranos intimidates professional sources and targets college students in court within the miniseries, with dozens of people representing millions who were hurt, some irreparably, by Holmes's company.
- Elizabeth Holmes tells “You Can See Everything” that the people portraying her are “playing a character I created,” exposing the unresolved tension between a natural personality and a consciously maintained persona.
- Elizabeth Holmes remains ambiguous in both productions: the series uses established facts to interrogate her, while the documentary uses her to interrogate the facts, leaving motive unresolved but action clear.
Why it matters: By centering chief scientist Ian Gibbons, Theranos executives and dozens of professional sources and students targeted in court, “The Dropout” makes the material stakes of Holmes's conviction visible: those people stand in for millions harmed, some irreparably. That wider lens keeps the series from treating the founder's inner motives as the only issue.
Ask SkimNews
