Barnwell Ranks Every NFL Playmaker Core, Dolphins Last
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- Bill Barnwell released his annual ranking of all 32 NFL offensive playmaker cores from worst to first, evaluating each team's top five skill-position contributors independent of quarterback, offensive line, and playcaller using traditional aging curves and historical draft-pick returns.
- Wide receivers carry the most weight in the methodology, with 25 averaging $20 million or more per year — compared to Saquon Barkley as the lone RB/TE above $20 million at $20.6M annually.
- Miami Dolphins rank No. 32 after sitting at No. 3 in 2024, with De'Von Achane the lone holdover from a previously elite group and Barnwell calling the receiving corps 'the worst assembled on purpose' in recent memory, featuring Jalen Tolbert and Tutu Atwell as veteran starters.
- New York Giants check in at No. 31, their ceiling capped by Malik Nabers' uncertain return from a knee injury nearly a year old and Cam Skattebo's recovery from a gruesome ankle injury that ended his rookie season, with Darnell Mooney replacing Wan'Dale Robinson and Odell Beckham Jr. returning though his last productive season was 2019.
- Cleveland Browns land at No. 30, banking on first-round WR KC Concepcion, second-round WR Denzel Boston, and tight end Harold Fannin Jr., who ranked ninth in yards per route run among tight ends in 2025.
- Buffalo Bills sit at No. 29 despite James Cook III's elite tackle-breaking and 5.2 yards per carry with 12 touchdowns, but his six regular-season fumbles (plus one in the playoffs) made him a negative-EPA rusher.
- The Seahawks' title run frames the entire exercise — Jaxon Smith-Njigba posted 153 yards and a TD in the NFC Championship, while Kenneth Walker III's 135-yard Super Bowl MVP day anchored the championship — yet Walker has since joined the Chiefs alongside A.J. Brown, Mike Evans, and Jaylen Waddle in a wave of offseason skill-position moves.
Why it matters: **Miami's freefall from No. 3 (2024) to dead last** — Barnwell's 'worst receiving corps assembled on purpose in recent memory' — illustrates how quickly a skill-position group collapses when veterans leave without replacements. Three other teams (Giants, Browns, Bills) all land in the bottom four due to injuries and youth, not talent pipelines.
