NCAA Weighs 5‑Year Eligibility Rule After Trump Order
Get the Sports newsletter
Daily sports — scores, transfers, the storylines from the leagues you actually follow. Free.
- NCAA is weighing a proposal that would set eligibility at five years based on high‑school graduation or the athlete’s 19th birthday, whichever comes first, with limited exceptions for military service, religious missions, and maternity leave.
- Trump issued an executive order less than a week ago directing the NCAA to create rules limiting athletes to a five‑year playing period and one free transfer before sitting out a season; the proposal was already in development before the order.
- Scott Schneider, a Title IX and employment attorney, highlighted a structural problem in the NCAA’s unincorporated association status that makes it vulnerable to state courts that may favor local universities over the national organization.
- Mit Winter, a college sports attorney, warned that the new uniform eligibility rule could face antitrust challenges, questioning whether it can withstand such legal scrutiny.
- Mihailo Petrovic, a 22‑year‑old sophomore at Illinois, could see his remaining eligibility reduced to two years under the new rule, prompting calls for greater scrutiny of age reporting for European recruits.
- NCAA’s Division I cabinet will discuss the proposal, and sources expressed optimism that it could be passed, though no timeline is set.
Why it matters: Student‑athletes gain a clear, uniform eligibility window, while the NCAA reduces exposure to inconsistent state‑court rulings and potential antitrust lawsuits; however, the rule could cut the playing time of older recruits and European players, reshaping recruiting strategies and may limit the financial upside from NIL deals for those who lose a season.
